Questa è una versione PDF del contenuto. Per la versione completa e aggiornata, visita:
https://blog.tuttosemplice.com/en/mortgage-usury-how-to-spot-it-and-protect-yourself/
Verrai reindirizzato automaticamente...
Buying a home is a fundamental step in many people’s lives, a dream often intertwined with the Italian cultural tradition of “il mattone” (brick and mortar) as the ultimate safe-haven asset. However, this journey can hide complex pitfalls, such as bank usury, a phenomenon that turns a future investment into a potential financial nightmare. Understanding what mortgage usury is, how to identify it, and what legal tools are available for protection is the first step to safeguarding your assets and peace of mind. In an increasingly integrated European market, transparency and awareness become the consumer’s best allies.
The concept of usury isn’t just about a high interest rate, but an illegal condition that occurs when the total cost of a loan exceeds a specific threshold set by law. Identifying it is not always straightforward, as it can be hidden behind seemingly legitimate cost items. Fortunately, Italian law, in line with European directives, offers effective tools to challenge these practices and obtain justice. This article serves as a practical guide to navigating the complexities of mortgage usury, providing clear information and concrete actions to take.
Bank usury is a crime defined by Article 644 of the Italian Penal Code and regulated by Law 108/1996. In simple terms, usury occurs when a bank or financial institution applies interest or total costs on a loan that exceed a maximum limit, known as the “threshold rate” (tasso soglia). This limit is not arbitrary but is set quarterly by the Ministry of Economy and Finance, based on the Average Overall Effective Rates (Tassi Effettivi Globali Medi – TEGM) recorded by the Bank of Italy. The purpose of the law is to protect citizens and businesses from excessively burdensome and potentially unsustainable credit conditions. It is crucial to understand that usury does not only concern the nominal interest but the entirety of the costs associated with granting the credit.
The Average Overall Effective Rate (TEGM) represents the average interest charged by banks and intermediaries for specific categories of transactions, such as mortgages, loans, or lines of credit. To calculate the threshold rate, the TEGM is increased by one-quarter (25%), and a further margin of 4 percentage points is added to this result. However, the difference between the threshold rate and the TEGM cannot exceed 8 percentage points. If the Annual Percentage Rate (APR), known in Italy as TAEG (Tasso Annuo Effettivo Globale), of the mortgage, which includes all mandatory fees, exceeds this threshold at the time of signing, the contract is considered usurious. The tables with the updated threshold rates are public and can be consulted on the websites of the Bank of Italy and the Ministry of Economy.
It is important to distinguish between two different types of usury, which have different legal consequences. Original usury (usura originaria) occurs when the agreed-upon interest rate and costs exceed the threshold rate at the time the mortgage contract is signed. In this case, the interest clause is considered void: the client will not have to pay any interest, but only repay the principal received (Art. 1815 of the Italian Civil Code). On the other hand, supervening usury (usura sopravvenuta) occurs when an initially legitimate rate exceeds the threshold during the term of the loan, due to a decrease in market rates. The case law on this point is complex, but recent rulings from the Court of Cassation have clarified that, even in this case, the bank’s claim for the portion exceeding the threshold is illegitimate, and the client is entitled to a recalculation.
To check if a mortgage is usurious, it’s not enough to look only at the Nominal Annual Rate (TAN); you must consider the Annual Percentage Rate (APR), known as TAEG in Italy. In fact, the usury law states that the calculation must include all commissions, remunerations, and expenses related to the provision of credit, with the exception of taxes. This means the calculation includes costs such as loan application fees, appraisal fees, payment processing fees, and, most importantly, premiums for mandatory insurance policies required by the bank, such as fire and explosion insurance. The Court of Cassation has repeatedly confirmed this all-inclusive principle to prevent banks from circumventing the law by loading “hidden” costs onto the client. For a correct assessment, it is crucial to know the difference between the various cost indicators, as explained in our guide on TAN and TAEG (APR).
Recognizing a potential case of usury requires attention to the details in the mortgage contract. A first red flag is the presence of very high initial costs, such as application fees that are disproportionate to the loan amount. Another key clue relates to insurance policies. If the bank required you to take out a life insurance policy (CPI – Credit Protection Insurance) as a condition for granting the mortgage, its cost must be included in the APR (TAEG) calculation for usury purposes. Often, these policies are presented as optional, but in reality, they are an indispensable requirement. It is essential to carefully read every clause before signing, as suggested in our guide to the mortgage deed. A lack of transparency on total costs or the presence of generic safeguard clauses that do not clearly specify compliance with threshold rates can be further warning signs.
If you suspect your mortgage is usurious, it is essential to act in a structured manner. The first step, which is indispensable for legal standing, is to commission an econometric analysis report (perizia econometrica). This document, prepared by a qualified professional, analyzes the contract and the amortization schedule to calculate the actual APR (TAEG) and compare it with the threshold rate in effect at the time of signing. With the report in hand, you can proceed with a formal complaint to the bank’s designated office. If the bank does not respond or denies the irregularity, you can turn to the Banking and Financial Arbitrator (ABF), an out-of-court dispute resolution system. As a last resort, you can take legal action in court to request that the interest clause be declared void and to demand the return of sums unduly paid.
The econometric report is not a simple simulation but a technical and legal analysis that constitutes the main piece of evidence in a usury dispute. Without this document, it is nearly impossible to prove your case. The expert analyzes all contractual documentation, including insurance policies and ancillary costs, to determine the real cost of the loan. This tool is crucial not only for initiating legal action but also during negotiations with the bank. A well-prepared report exponentially increases the chances of success, making it possible to obtain a refund of the interest paid and, in cases of original usury, to convert the mortgage into an interest-free loan, protecting the debtor from serious consequences like real estate foreclosure.
The Italian dream of homeownership is rooted in a strong cultural tradition, but today it is achieved through modern and complex financial instruments. In this scenario, innovation plays a key role in consumer protection. Online platforms and digital tools, such as an online mortgage simulator, allow you to compare offers and get an initial idea of the costs. The increasing digitalization of the banking sector, while speeding up transactions, also requires greater awareness from customers. Financial education, also promoted by institutions like the Bank of Italy, becomes a pillar for a more balanced relationship between bank and client, combining the prudence of tradition with the power of digital information to make safe and informed choices.
Tackling the issue of bank usury on mortgages requires an informed and proactive approach. The dream of a home, deeply rooted in our culture, must not be compromised by illegal financial practices. The law provides a clear definition of usury through the threshold rate mechanism, and case law has consolidated the principle that all costs related to the credit, including insurance policies, must be included in the verification calculation. If you have doubts about the regularity of your mortgage, the path to follow is clear: from the econometric report to the complaint, and even legal action, there are concrete tools to assert your rights. Knowledge is the first form of defense: being an informed consumer means protecting your financial future and turning the purchase of a home into a serene and secure investment, just as tradition dictates.
To check if your mortgage is usurious, you must compare the Annual Percentage Rate (APR), or TAEG, of your loan with the ‘threshold rate’ (tasso soglia) set quarterly by the Bank of Italy. The APR includes all mandatory mortgage costs (interest, application fees, appraisal, mandatory insurance). If the APR exceeds the threshold rate valid at the time the contract was signed, the mortgage involves original usury. You can find the updated threshold rates on the Bank of Italy’s website or in the Official Gazette (Gazzetta Ufficiale).
‘Original usury’ occurs when the interest rate agreed upon in the mortgage contract exceeds the legal threshold from the very beginning. ‘Supervening usury,’ on the other hand, occurs when an initially legal rate exceeds the threshold during the loan term due to a decrease in market rates. The prevailing case law, including rulings from the United Sections of the Court of Cassation, tends to primarily recognize the legal relevance of original usury, establishing that if the interest was legal at the time it was agreed upon, it does not become illegal later.
If original usury is confirmed, the law provides very advantageous consequences for the borrower. According to Article 1815 of the Italian Civil Code, the interest clause is void, and no interest of any kind is due. This means you will only have to repay the remaining principal of the loan to the bank, and you are entitled to a refund of all interest already paid.
If you suspect your mortgage is usurious, the first thing to do is request an econometric analysis report from professionals specializing in banking law, such as lawyers or consulting firms. These experts will analyze your contract and calculate the actual APR (TAEG). If the result is positive, you can initiate legal action against the bank to have the interest declared void and obtain a refund of what was unduly paid.
Yes, the right to request the return of interest unduly paid due to usury has a 10-year statute of limitations. The legal debate concerns the starting point for this period (dies a quo). The most recent case law indicates that, as it is a single debt with installment repayments, the statute of limitations begins to run from the payment of the last mortgage installment, as only at that moment is the contract’s execution complete.