Questa è una versione PDF del contenuto. Per la versione completa e aggiornata, visita:
https://blog.tuttosemplice.com/en/web-analytics-beyond-google-for-your-privacy/
Verrai reindirizzato automaticamente...
Anyone who manages a website, from a small personal blog to a large e-commerce site, knows how crucial it is to analyze traffic data. Understanding where visitors come from, which pages they prefer, and how they interact with content is the key to growing online. For decades, the go-to tool for this task has been Google Analytics. However, a growing debate over user privacy and new, stringent regulations have challenged its undisputed dominance. In this context, especially in Italy and Europe, the way has been paved for new solutions that prioritize respect for personal data.
The issue is no longer just technical, but legal and ethical. The Italian Data Protection Authority (Garante per la protezione dei dati personali), as well as other European authorities, has raised significant concerns about the use of Google Analytics. The main problem lies in the transfer of European users’ data to servers located in the United States, a country considered to lack an adequate level of protection under GDPR rules. This has created an urgent need for companies and professionals to find valid alternatives that are both legally compliant and effective. Exploring these options is not just a move to avoid fines, but a strategic choice to build a relationship of trust with your audience.
The push to look beyond Google Analytics doesn’t just stem from an abstract desire for change, but from specific legal and operational needs. The digital ecosystem is evolving rapidly, with greater user awareness of their privacy and an increasingly defined regulatory framework. Ignoring these changes means exposing your business to concrete risks, both in terms of penalties and reputation. Understanding the reasons for this transition is the first step toward making an informed choice that is geared toward the future of the web.
At the heart of the problem is the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), the European law that protects citizens’ privacy. Several data protection authorities, including Italy’s, have determined that the use of Google Analytics can violate GDPR. The reason is related to the transfer of personal data, such as IP addresses, to the United States. After the Schrems II ruling by the Court of Justice of the European Union, which invalidated the previous “Privacy Shield” agreement, this transfer became problematic. For an Italian company, using non-compliant tools means risking fines and, above all, losing the trust of its customers, who are increasingly mindful of how their information is handled. For this reason, it is crucial to ensure you have a GDPR-compliant site.
Beyond the legal issues, the evolution of the tool itself has also prompted many to look elsewhere. The transition from Universal Analytics to Google Analytics 4 (GA4) represented a significant break. The new model, based on “events” rather than “sessions,” has a steeper learning curve and has disoriented many users accustomed to the old interface. Furthermore, the free version of GA4 uses data sampling for complex reports, which means that analyses may not be based on 100% of the traffic, introducing potential inaccuracies. Finally, the collected data remains within Google’s ecosystem, giving the site owner limited control and no true ownership of the data itself.
Fortunately, the market now offers numerous alternatives to Google Analytics that were designed from the ground up with privacy at their core. These tools, often open source, not only help with GDPR compliance but also offer a more streamlined user experience focused on essential metrics. Choosing a “privacy-first” option means adopting a technology that measures traffic without tracking individuals, eliminating the need for annoying cookie banners and strengthening transparency with visitors.
Matomo, formerly known as Piwik, is one of the most mature and comprehensive alternatives. Its main feature is flexibility: it can be used as a Cloud service (with servers in Europe) or installed on your own server (On-Premise). The latter option guarantees 100% data ownership and control, a decisive advantage for GDPR compliance. Matomo offers detailed reports, similar to those of Google Analytics, without data sampling. It is a powerful and customizable platform, also chosen by institutions like the European Commission. The disadvantage of the self-hosted version is that it requires technical skills for installation and maintenance, while the Cloud version has a monthly cost.
Plausible Analytics is the epitome of simplicity and lightweight design. It is an open-source tool whose tracking script weighs less than 1 KB, a fraction of Google Analytics’, so it does not slow down your site. Plausible does not use cookies and does not collect personal data, making it fully GDPR compliant out of the box. Its dashboard is intuitive and displays all essential metrics on a single page. This minimalist approach is ideal for those looking for clear, actionable data without the complexity of more advanced tools. Plausible is a paid service, but its cost is transparent and justified by its ease of use and strong focus on privacy.
Similar to Plausible in philosophy, Fathom Analytics focuses on simplicity and privacy. It also does not use cookies and provides aggregated, anonymous data analysis, ensuring compliance with regulations. Fathom is praised for its clean interface and fast loading speed. It is designed for those who want an overview of their site’s performance without getting lost in a sea of data. Like Plausible, it is a paid alternative that aims for a sustainable business model based on subscriptions rather than data exploitation. The choice between Fathom and Plausible often comes down to personal preferences regarding the interface and minor functional differences.
In a cultural context like Italy and the Mediterranean, where personal relationships and trust are central values, adopting privacy-respecting web analytics takes on a special meaning. We can see it as a fusion of tradition and innovation. Tradition is represented by the value placed on the direct relationship with the customer, a bond based on mutual trust reminiscent of the artisan shops of the past, where the shopkeeper knew his patrons by name. In this scenario, the customer is not just a number or a profile to be monetized.
The innovation lies in using modern technological tools, like Matomo or Plausible, to support this ethical approach. Instead of collecting vast amounts of personal data, these platforms focus on the information that is truly useful for improving the service offered. Choosing an alternative to Google Analytics thus becomes a gesture that goes beyond legal compliance. It is a statement of intent: a way of telling your users that their privacy is a priority, strengthening a bond of trust that, in the long run, is far more valuable than any demographic data. It is the digital equivalent of a sincere handshake.
Choosing the ideal web analytics platform depends on an honest assessment of your needs, skills, and resources. There is no one-size-fits-all solution, but there is one that is best suited for your project. The first factor to consider is your budget. If you’re looking for a free solution, Matomo On-Premise is a powerful option, but remember to include the indirect costs related to the server and maintenance time. If you prefer a fixed and predictable cost, services like Plausible, Fathom, or Matomo Cloud offer affordable monthly plans.
Another crucial element is technical expertise. Are you comfortable managing a server and installing software? Matomo On-Premise will give you maximum control. If you prefer a turnkey solution that works in minutes, cloud-based alternatives are the best choice. Finally, evaluate your actual analysis needs. Do you need complex reports, advanced segmentation, and tracking of dozens of conversions, typical of a large e-commerce site? Matomo might be more suitable. If, on the other hand, you just need to know where your traffic is coming from and which content is most read to manage a successful blog, the simplicity of Plausible or Fathom will be more than enough.
The web analytics landscape is undergoing a monumental transformation, driven by greater privacy awareness and an increasingly influential regulatory framework, the GDPR. The era of Google Analytics’ undisputed dominance is giving way to a more diverse ecosystem, where protecting user data is no longer an option, but a necessity. Platforms like Matomo, Plausible, and Fathom show that it is possible to obtain valuable data on your website’s traffic without compromising the privacy and trust of your visitors.
Moving away from Google Analytics is not just a move to shield yourself from potential fines, but a strategic and value-driven choice. It means communicating a message of transparency and respect to your audience, elements that are now essential for building a solid and lasting reputation. Whether you choose the power and control of Matomo or the simplicity and lightness of Plausible, the future of the web belongs to those who can balance technological innovation with ethics, always putting people first.
Looking for a Google Analytics alternative is a strategic choice for many businesses, especially in Europe. The main reasons are privacy and GDPR compliance. Several European data protection authorities have raised doubts about Google Analytics’ compliance, as European users’ data can be transferred to the United States. Furthermore, the complexity of Google Analytics 4 (GA4) prompts many to seek simpler, more intuitive tools. Alternatives often offer more straightforward interfaces and greater control over your data.
There are several excellent privacy-focused alternatives. Among the most popular are Matomo, Plausible Analytics, and Fathom Analytics. **Matomo** is a very comprehensive open-source platform, available in both cloud and self-hosted versions, that gives you full data ownership. **Plausible** is known for its simplicity, lightweight script (less than 1KB), and for being completely cookieless by default. **Fathom Analytics** is also a highly regarded option for its minimal interface and ethical approach, which does not require cookie banners. There are also emerging Italian solutions like Publytics.
The issue is complex. Several European Data Protection Authorities, including Italy’s, have ruled that using previous versions of Google Analytics without adequate safeguards violated GDPR due to the transfer of personal data to the United States. Although Google has introduced measures with GA4 and a new data transfer agreement (the EU-US Data Privacy Framework) has been signed, a gray area persists that does not completely eliminate legal risks. For this reason, many companies prefer to adopt European solutions or specific configurations to ensure compliance.
A ‘cookieless’ alternative means the analytics tool does not use cookies—small text files saved on the user’s browser—to track visits. This approach is more privacy-respecting because it does not follow the user across different sessions or websites. Tools like Plausible and Fathom are ‘cookieless’ by default. This allows for the collection of aggregated and anonymous data on visits without storing personal information, often eliminating the need to display a consent banner for analytics cookies.
It depends on the tool. Some platforms, like **Matomo** (in its On-Premise version) and **Umami**, are open-source software and can be installed for free on your own servers, with you only paying for hosting costs. Most other popular alternatives, such as Plausible, Fathom Analytics, and the Cloud version of Matomo, are paid services (SaaS – Software as a Service) with a monthly or annual subscription, which usually varies based on the website’s traffic volume. There are also free plans for sites with very low traffic, such as the one offered by Microanalytics.