Questa è una versione PDF del contenuto. Per la versione completa e aggiornata, visita:
https://blog.tuttosemplice.com/en/car-insurance-save-with-the-bersani-law-and-bonus-malus-system/
Verrai reindirizzato automaticamente...
In Italian culture, the automobile has never been just a simple means of transportation. It represents a symbol of freedom, an extension of the home, and often, a treasure to be jealously guarded. However, maintaining this passion comes at an ever-increasing cost. Recent analyses by IVASS confirm that insurance premiums in our country have started to rise again, forcing families to seek smart strategies to balance their budgets without sacrificing safety.
In this complex scenario, where the Mediterranean driving tradition meets the innovation of financial markets, navigating the regulations becomes essential. It’s not just about finding the lowest price, but about understanding the mechanisms that govern risk and merit. Legislative tools like the Bersani Law and the more recent Family Car Insurance (RC Familiare) offer concrete opportunities to cut costs, but they require precise knowledge of the rules.
Informed savings start with information. Understanding how your driving history affects the final premium and how to leverage the benefits granted to your household is the first step toward efficient financial management. In this article, we will explore how to turn bureaucratic obligations into economic advantages, analyzing the Italian context in relation to European standards.
True insurance savings don’t come from cutting coverage, but from intelligently optimizing your merit class within the family unit.
The beating heart of car insurance in Italy is the Bonus-Malus system. This mechanism rewards virtuous drivers and penalizes those who cause accidents, based on a scale known as Universal Classes (CU). The scale ranges from class 18, the most expensive and intended for the riskiest profiles, to class 1, which guarantees the most favorable rates. Every driver is the architect of their own financial destiny: a year without claims allows you to move down one class, earning the “bonus.”
Conversely, causing an accident results in the application of the “malus.” This not only means an increase in the premium but also a demotion of two merit classes. It’s a system that reflects an almost reputational logic, deeply rooted in our culture: good conduct is rewarded over time, building a solid insurance history. To delve deeper into the technical dynamics of this mechanism, it is useful to consult a specific guide on the car insurance bonus-malus system.
The system is designed to make the driver accountable. However, for those entering the world of driving for the first time, like new drivers, the standard starting point is class 14. This decidedly expensive entry point has often represented a significant economic barrier for new generations, making four-wheeled independence a luxury that is difficult to afford without outside help.
In 2007, the Italian insurance landscape underwent an epochal shift with the introduction of the Bersani Law. This regulation introduced a principle of family equity, allowing new vehicle owners to bypass the hurdle of class 14. The law allows the owner of a newly purchased vehicle, whether new or used, to inherit the merit class of a cohabiting family member. The fundamental requirement is that both individuals appear on the same Certificate of Family Status (Stato di Famiglia).
The social impact was enormous. Suddenly, a new driver could benefit from a parent’s virtuous driving record, perhaps accessing class 1 and saving hundreds of euros on the annual premium. This rule reinforced the concept of intergenerational solidarity, typical of Italian society, allowing families to manage their household vehicle fleet with greater financial peace of mind.
However, the original Bersani Law had specific limitations. The benefit applied exclusively to vehicles of the same type: a car could only inherit a class from another car, and a motorcycle from a motorcycle. Furthermore, the benefit was valid only for new policies on additional vehicles (“new” to the household) and could not be applied to renewals of existing contracts.
Regulatory innovation did not stop in 2007. With the entry into force of Family Car Insurance (RC Auto Familiare) in February 2020, lawmakers aimed to further expand the scope of savings. This evolution of the Bersani Law broke down the barriers between different types of vehicles. Today, it is possible to transfer the merit class even between different categories, for example, from a car to a scooter, offering unprecedented flexibility for mixed urban mobility.
The real revolution, however, concerns renewals. While the Bersani Law only applied to new purchases, Family Car Insurance allows the merit class to be adjusted even for policies already in effect at the time of annual renewal. If there is a virtuous driver in class 1 in the family, all other members can theoretically align with that level, provided they meet a fundamental requirement of a “clean” insurance record.
To access the benefits of Family Car Insurance, it is essential not to have caused any at-fault, principally at-fault, or shared-fault accidents in the last 5 years.
This five-year condition ensures that the benefit is extended only to those who have demonstrated real reliability behind the wheel, preventing abuse of the system. To better understand the nuances between the two regulations and choose the most suitable one, it is advisable to read an in-depth article on family car insurance.
Analyzing the cost of car insurance in Italy requires a comparative look at our European neighbors. Historically, Italian drivers have paid significantly higher premiums than their French, German, or Spanish counterparts. The reasons are multiple and rooted in a combination of factors: a high density of vehicles in historic urban areas, a frequent accident rate, and, unfortunately, a long tradition of insurance fraud that has inflated costs for everyone.
However, the gap is narrowing. Thanks to increased competition and the introduction of targeted laws, the “gap” with Europe has shrunk, although it still exists. Data shows that while Europe tends to favor standardization, in Italy the market is extremely responsive to local specifics. Rates vary drastically from province to province, reflecting the diversity of the territory, from chaotic metropolises to quiet provincial towns.
In this context, the Italian driver must be savvier than the European average. It’s not enough to tacitly renew the policy; it’s necessary to become an active player in the market, comparing quotes and leveraging every regulatory loophole. For a complete overview of cost-reduction tactics, it can be useful to consult strategies on how to save on car insurance.
If legal tradition gave us the Bersani Law, technology has offered us the “black box.” Italy is the absolute leader in Europe for the penetration of insurance telematics. Millions of drivers have chosen to install this satellite device in their car in exchange for a substantial discount on their policy. It is a perfect example of how digital innovation has adapted to the savings needs of families.
The black box records crucial data such as speed, acceleration, and accident dynamics. This tool acts as an impartial witness, reducing disputes and allowing companies to better profile risk. For the policyholder, accepting this monitoring means giving up a small amount of privacy in exchange for a tangible and immediate economic advantage.
Beyond the black box, innovation also includes “pay-per-use” or mileage-based plans, ideal for those who use their car sporadically. These solutions reward the actual use of the vehicle rather than mere ownership, disrupting the old fixed-rate model. Those who drive few miles can find great value in these policies, as explained in the article dedicated to pay-as-you-drive and usage-based car insurance.
Beyond laws and technology, there are contractual levers that every driver can use. One of the most effective is managing deductibles and excesses. Agreeing to cover a small part of the damage out-of-pocket in case of an accident (the deductible) can drastically lower the annual premium cost. It’s a bet on one’s own prudence that often pays off.
Another crucial aspect is the choice of the coverage limit. Although the law imposes minimums, stopping at the basic threshold might not be wise in case of a serious accident. Increasing the coverage limit often costs just a few dollars more but provides essential asset protection. To correctly balance protection and expense, it is essential to evaluate how much car insurance coverage to choose.
Finally, one should not underestimate the payment method. Many companies offer discounts for those who pay the premium in a single installment or use specific credit cards. The best approach is a holistic one: combine the advantages of the Bersani Law or Family Car Insurance with a telematics policy and a smart deductible. Only by adding up these small advantages can a macroscopic saving be achieved.
Saving on car insurance in Italy is not an operation that can be solved with a simple click. It requires an understanding of the dynamics that link family history to individual conduct. From the rigidity of the Bonus-Malus system to the flexibility of Family Car Insurance, lawmakers have provided powerful tools to protect the purchasing power of families, but it is up to the consumer to know how to activate them.
Technological innovation, through telematics, has offered further support, rewarding transparency and real prudence on the road. In a market that remains one of the most complex in Europe, the real resource is awareness. Maintaining a clean driving record is not just a civic duty, but the best financial investment a driver can make for their economic future.
The Bersani Law allows the owner of a purchased vehicle (new or used) to acquire the same merit class as another already insured vehicle, provided that both owners live in the same household. This avoids starting from the expensive 14th class.
Family Car Insurance is more extensive: it allows the class to be transferred even between different types of vehicles (e.g., from a car to a motorcycle) and also applies to renewals of existing policies, whereas the Bersani Law was only valid for new contracts and vehicles of the same type.
For Family Car Insurance, no. A clean claims history (no at-fault accidents) for the last 5 years is required. For the standard Bersani Law on a new vehicle, the main requirement is the family status certificate, but the beneficiary’s prior insurance history can have an impact.
No, you don’t lose your class. Thanks to the electronic Certificate of Risk, your insurance history and your universal merit class (CU) follow you everywhere. You can switch companies while keeping all the benefits you’ve earned.
Generally, yes. Companies offer significant discounts to those who install a black box because it reduces the risk of fraud and helps reconstruct accident dynamics. However, always check the privacy conditions and contractual obligations.