In Brief (TL;DR)
Understanding the difference between TAN and APR is crucial to knowing the real cost of a mortgage and consciously choosing the most advantageous offer.
The APR, unlike the TAN, is the indicator that includes all ancillary and mandatory fees, offering a clear and complete view of the mortgage’s real cost.
Therefore, fully understanding the difference between these two rates is the first step toward a conscious and beneficial financial choice.
The devil is in the details. 👇 Keep reading to discover the critical steps and practical tips to avoid mistakes.
Buying a home is a dream deeply rooted in Italian culture, a step that symbolizes stability and the future. But delving into the world of mortgages can feel like navigating an obstacle course, littered with acronyms and technical terms. Among these, TAN and APR are the undisputed main characters. Understanding the difference between these two indicators isn’t just a financial exercise; it’s the fundamental tool for grasping the total cost of your loan and avoiding unpleasant surprises. This article was created to bring clarity, guiding everyone, from young professionals to established families, toward an informed and transparent choice.
The goal is simple: to turn uncertainty into knowledge. We will analyze what these two percentages represent, what costs they include, and why one is much more important than the other when comparing bank offers. With practical examples and straightforward language, we will reveal how proper information is the first and most important building block for your home project, blending the traditional “dream of homeownership” with the innovation of more conscious personal finance.
TAN: The Pure Interest Rate
The TAN, an acronym for Tasso Annuo Nominale (Nominal Annual Rate), represents the pure interest rate applied to the capital the bank lends us. In simple terms, it’s the “price” of the money we borrow, expressed on an annual basis. When a bank offers us a mortgage with a certain TAN, it is communicating only the percentage of interest we will have to pay back on the financed capital. This rate is the basic element for calculating the mortgage payment, particularly the interest portion, which, especially in the early years of a French amortization plan, makes up a significant part of the monthly payment. However, the TAN is a partial indicator because it doesn’t account for any other costs associated with the loan. Looking only at the TAN is like choosing a product at the supermarket based solely on the shelf price, without considering additional costs at the checkout.
The APR: The Total Cost Indicator
The APR, or Annual Percentage Rate (known in Italian as TAEG, Tasso Annuo Effettivo Globale), is the indicator that makes the real difference. Known at the European level as ISC (Indicatore Sintetico di Costo, or Synthetic Cost Indicator), its purpose is to provide a complete and transparent view of the total cost of the loan. In addition to the TAN, the APR includes a series of mandatory ancillary fees that affect the final cost of the mortgage. The main ones include: loan origination fees, property appraisal costs, mandatory insurance policies (such as fire and hazard insurance), taxes, and any account management fees if required by the bank. By law, thanks to European transparency directives, every credit institution is required to disclose the APR in every offer and pre-contractual document, thus allowing for a fair and immediate comparison between various proposals. This is the number to look at to understand which mortgage is truly more affordable.
TAN vs. APR: A Practical Example
To understand the importance of not stopping at the TAN, a practical example is worth a thousand words. Imagine having to choose between two mortgage offers for €150,000 over 25 years.
- Bank A offers a 2.90% TAN. The origination fees are €1,500, the appraisal costs €300, and there are no other initial fees.
- Bank B catches your eye with a lower TAN of 2.80%. However, its origination fees are €2,500 and the appraisal is €400.
At first glance, Bank B’s offer seems more advantageous due to its lower TAN. But when we calculate the APR, which includes all costs, the perspective changes. Bank B’s higher ancillary fees will inevitably drive up its APR, which could end up being higher than Bank A’s. For example, Bank A’s APR might be 3.05%, while Bank B’s could rise to 3.10%. This shows that a lower TAN does not guarantee a cheaper mortgage. The comparison must always be made using the APR, the only indicator that reveals the “all-inclusive” cost of the loan.
Why Transparency Is a Consumer Right
The clear disclosure of the APR is not a courtesy from banks, but an obligation established by specific European and national regulations, such as Directive 2014/17/EU. The goal of this legislation is to protect consumers by ensuring a more transparent and competitive credit market. In Italy, the Bank of Italy oversees financial intermediaries to ensure they comply with these rules, mandating maximum clarity in advertising and informational documents. The key document in this process is the ESIS (European Standardised Information Sheet), which must be given to the client before the contract is signed. The ESIS summarizes all the economic conditions of the offer, highlighting the APR to facilitate comparison between different proposals on the market. Being aware of this right allows you to always demand clear and complete information.
Tradition and Innovation in Choosing a Mortgage
The desire to own a home is a tradition deeply rooted in our culture, a milestone that unites generations. While in the past, the choice of a bank was based on word-of-mouth or a relationship of trust with the local branch, today technological innovation has revolutionized this process. Understanding the difference between TAN and APR is the perfect example of how a modern skill is essential to achieving an age-old dream. Digital tools, online comparison sites, and financial information blogs have democratized access to information, allowing anyone to analyze and compare dozens of offers. Knowing how to read this data correctly is a crucial skill. Navigating the path to applying for a first-time homebuyer mortgage with this new awareness means combining the value of tradition with the power of innovation, for a choice that is not only dreamed of, but also informed and secure.
Conclusion
In summary, the distinction between TAN and APR is clear and fundamental. The TAN only indicates the interest rate applied to the principal, offering a partial view of the mortgage’s cost. The APR, in contrast, is the all-inclusive indicator that encompasses all mandatory costs associated with the loan, representing the true total cost of credit. For this reason, when comparing different mortgage offers, the only parameter that guarantees a fair and transparent comparison is the APR. An attractive TAN can hide high ancillary fees that make the loan more expensive than other seemingly less convenient proposals. Being an informed consumer, able to decipher these acronyms and demand clarity, is the first step to turning the dream of a home into a solid financial reality, without any surprises.
Frequently Asked Questions
The TAN (Nominal Annual Rate) is the ‘pure’ interest rate the bank applies to the capital it lends you. It only indicates the cost of the interest. The APR (Annual Percentage Rate), on the other hand, is the indicator that expresses the total cost of the mortgage, because it includes not only the TAN but also all mandatory ancillary fees, such as origination costs, appraisals, required insurance policies, and administrative fees.
The APR is definitely more important. While a low TAN may seem attractive, it doesn’t tell the whole story. The APR, by including all mandatory fees, gives you a complete and realistic view of the total cost of the loan. To fairly compare different mortgage offers, the fundamental indicator to consider is always the APR.
A large difference between the APR and the TAN indicates that there are significant ancillary costs associated with the mortgage. These costs can include high origination fees, commissions, appraisals, or mandatory insurance policies. Therefore, an offer with a very low TAN but a disproportionately high APR might be hiding additional costs that make it less affordable than it first appears.
The APR includes: the TAN, loan origination fees, costs of mandatory insurance (like fire and hazard insurance), payment processing fees, and other bank commissions. Generally excluded from the APR calculation are non-mandatory or unpredictable costs, such as notary fees for the deed of sale and mortgage, taxes, prepayment penalties, and optional insurance policies.
It depends on the type of mortgage. In a fixed-rate mortgage, the TAN (and consequently the interest portion of the payment) remains unchanged for the entire loan term. In a variable-rate mortgage (or adjustable-rate mortgage, ARM), the TAN changes according to the fluctuations of a benchmark index (like the Euribor). Consequently, the APR of a variable-rate mortgage is also an estimate calculated at the time of closing and can vary over time.
Did you find this article helpful? Is there another topic you'd like to see me cover?
Write it in the comments below! I take inspiration directly from your suggestions.